How to Make a Custom Meme Game with Your Own Photos (DIY Personalized Gift)

a woman holding up a custom made meme game in front of a Christmas tree

My nephew is getting harder and harder to impress these days. Honestly, anytime I can get more than a polite smile out of him (clearly just humoring his dear old auntie), I could do a cartwheel I’m so happy.

And every birthday and Christmas, I find myself scratching my head trying to figure out a gift he’ll actually like. Although, at this age, I’m pretty sure cold, hard cash is becoming my safest bet.

But last Christmas, I came up with an idea that he later declared his FAVORITE Christmas present. I just about died.

A few years ago, I’d introduced my game-loving nephew to What Do You Meme?, and it’s become the game he always asks to play at my house. So I decided to take things a step further and make him his very own personalized meme game, complete with ridiculous family photos, inside jokes, and hilarious captions.

I called it Oh My Meme: The Noah Edition.

And the best part? You can make your own custom meme game, too!

I’ll walk you through how I designed everything in Canva, printed and cut the cards, and even made a surprisingly professional-looking game box using a couple of Dollar Tree finds. Plus, I’ll share a few things I learned along the way that could save you some time, money, and frustration.


Note: This post may contain affiliate links. Thank you for supporting The Savvy Swaréy. Learn more.


What Is a Custom Meme Game?

If you’ve ever played a meme caption game, you already know how hilarious they can get.

The concept is simple: One player selects a photo card, and everyone else chooses a caption from their hand that they think makes the funniest combination. The player judging the round picks their favorite, and whoever submitted that caption wins the point.

Now imagine playing that game with photos of your own family and friends.

That’s exactly what I did.

custom made DIY meme game finished

Instead of using random internet memes, I collected some of the funniest photos I could find of my nephew, his friends, and our family. Then I created caption cards inspired by their personalities, inside jokes, and the ridiculous things teenagers say.

The result was a completely personalized game that was just as much fun to make as it was to give.

If you’re looking for a creative kids Christmas gift idea, or unique way to make a kids birthday extra special, this is a guaranteed hit.


flat lay spread of printed and cut meme game photo and caption cards and packaging and cutting supplies used

Supplies You’ll Need to Make a DIY Meme Game

You don’t need a ton of supplies or any special crafting equipment to make your own game (though I’ve included a few shortcuts I used).

Here’s what you’ll need:

  • Canva: To design the photo cards, caption cards, game instructions, and cover.
  • Personal photos: The funnier and more ridiculous, the better!
  • Cardstock or professional printing service: I used matte cover stock from FedEx Office. The quality was excellent.
  • Paper cutter or scissors: To cut your finished cards.
    • Optional: corner-rounding punch if you want rounded playing-card edges
    • Both the paper cutter and corner-rounder I use are linked in my DIY Project tools
  • Plastic pencil case: I found a hard plastic case at Dollar Tree that worked perfectly for packaging.
  • Mini wooden easel: Also from Dollar Tree, to display the photo card during each round.
  • Hot glue gun or Super Glue: To attach the instructions inside the case.

Make Your Own Meme Game Instructions

We’ll go through this step-by-step, but in a nutshell, here’s what you’ll do.

  1. Pick your photos
  2. Create your captions
  3. Design your cards (a Free Canva account is all you need)
  4. Prep your designs for printing
  5. Print your cards
  6. Cut and assemble

Want to save a ton of time creating your own?!
I’ve created an editable template that’s done for you. All you have to do is swap your photos and customize your game.

funny meme game photo card of a little girl running over her brother in an ATV

Step 1: Choose Your Funniest Photos

This might be the most entertaining part of the entire project.

Start scrolling through your camera roll, family group chats, and shared photo albums to find pictures that would make hilarious meme cards.

And don’t worry about finding perfect pictures. In fact, the more awkward, unexpected, or ridiculous the photo, the better.

For my nephew’s game, I included a mix of:

  • Funny close-up selfies and ridiculous facial expressions.
  • Embarrassing childhood photos.
  • Photos of friends doing questionable things.
  • Family members caught in funny moments.
  • His dog, because obviously the dog needed to make an appearance.

How Many Photo Cards Should You Make?

I’d suggest starting with around 20–30 photo cards and 60–80 caption cards. That gives players plenty of combinations without making the project overwhelming.

I ended up making 22 photo cards and 78 caption cards for my game.

You can absolutely make more or fewer depending on how many people will be playing and how much time you want to spend creating it.

My tip: Choose a variety of photos with a good mix of expressions, people, and situations that could work with several different captions.

a woman holding up a funny caption from a custom meme game she made

Step 2: Come Up with Hilarious Meme Captions

This was probably the part I spent the most time on, but it was also one of my favorites.

I wanted the captions to feel like something you’d find in a real meme game, but with enough personalized references that my nephew and his friends would recognize the jokes.

I started by thinking about his personality, his friends, and the things they find funny.

For example, my nephew is obsessed with winning, loves basketball, and is slightly obsessed with Byrne Dairy (for some reason). His younger sister also has some pretty serious gremlin energy, so naturally, that all made its way into the game.

Different Types of Meme Captions to Try

1. Funny, relatable situations

These work especially well because they can match so many different photos.

Examples:

  • “When you accidentally sneeze on school picture day.”
  • “When you say ‘watch this’ and immediately regret it.”
  • “When you thought it would be funny until it happened to you.”

2. POV captions

POV (point-of-view) captions are perfect for awkward facial expressions and reaction photos.

Examples:

  • “POV: grounded immediately.”
  • “POV: you’re about to regret it.”
  • “POV: it is absolutely your fault.”

3. Inside jokes and personalized references

This is where your game really becomes one of a kind.

Some of my favorites included:

  • “Mentally, I’m at Byrne Dairy. Physically, I’m here.”
  • “The moment you realize your sister is actually a gremlin.”
  • “Dinky did it. Don’t look at me.”

Obviously, those won’t mean much to someone outside our family, but that’s kind of the point!

4. Short, sarcastic reactions

You also want a handful of shorter captions that work with almost any photo.

Examples:

  • “Lowkey iconic.”
  • “Be so serious right now.”
  • “Bro, it’s not that serious.”

TIME SAVER: Get Meme Caption Ideas Using ChatGPT

Here’s a little shortcut that made this process much easier: I used ChatGPT to help brainstorm captions.

I shared details about my nephew’s personality, his friends, his favorite sayings, and our family inside jokes. Then I uploaded some of the photos and asked for funny captions that would work with them.

We went through several rounds of ideas before I narrowed everything down to my favorites.

If you want to try this yourself, here’s a prompt you can copy and customize:

Copy-and-Paste ChatGPT Prompt:

“I’m making a personalized meme card game for [person or group]. The game will include funny photos of our family and friends, and I need hilarious caption cards that can be mixed and matched with different pictures.

Here’s some background about the people playing: [Add ages, personalities, inside jokes, favorite sayings, hobbies, and funny stories.]

Help me brainstorm a mix of short reactions, relatable ‘When you…’ scenarios, POV captions, funny misunderstandings, and personalized inside jokes.

Keep the humor [family-friendly / PG-13 / adult], and make the captions funny enough to stand on their own but versatile enough to work with multiple photos. Avoid repeating the same joke or sentence structure too often.”

My advice: Don’t settle for the first batch of captions. Keep the ones that genuinely make you laugh, then ask for more ideas in the styles you like best.

Step 3: Design Your Custom Meme Game in Canva

Once you have your photos and captions, it’s time to bring everything together.

I used Canva to design my entire game, including the photo cards, caption cards, instruction sheet, and game cover.

I wanted the finished game to feel like something you could actually buy in a store, so I kept the designs consistent with matching colors, fonts, and card backs.

Want to skip the design work?
Grab my editable Canva template to make creating your own personalized meme game even easier.

How to Design Your Meme Game Photo Cards

custom meme game photo cards being designed in Canva
  1. Start by creating a new 4” x 6” design in Canva.
  2. Upload your photos and place each one on its own page. Keep adding pages and photos until you’ve got them all placed. You may need to crop some images to fit, especially if you’re working with a mix of horizontal and vertical pictures.
  3. On a new page in the same design project, create your design for the back of the cards. For mine, I created a design with the words Oh My Meme: The Noah Edition, with an outline effect, on a blue background.

How to Design Your Meme Caption Cards

Custom caption cards for a DIY meme game being made in Canva
  1. Next, create a separate 2.5” x 3.5” design for your caption cards.
  2. Add your captions one per page. Don’t worry about the font style or color just yet. Just make sure they are a legible font size (I used size 12) and centered horizontally and vertically. To confirm, right click on the text box and select “Align to Page.” Select “Center” and “Middle.”
  3. Continue adding your captions, one per page until you’re done.
  4. Then, on your last caption, adjust the text to your preferred font and color. I chose a dark blue in Montserrat.

    When you change your font and text color, you’ll see these boxes pop up. Select “Change all” on both so it applies the font and color changes to ALL cards at once.
  5. On a new page in the same design project, create your design for the back of the cards with the same design as your photo cards. You can copy and paste design elements from your photo card project.

A few things to keep in mind:

  • Use a bold, easy-to-read font.
  • Center your text and leave enough space around the edges.
  • Make sure longer captions fit comfortably, especially after you’ve adjusted the font.
A custom designed instruction card and cover card for a DIY meme game being prepped to cut with a Cameo machine

Create Your Game Cover and Instructions

I also designed a matching cover and a rules card in Canva, sizing both pieces to fit the plastic pencil case I found at the Dollar Tree. If you go this route as well, I used 6.75” x 3.5.”

For the instruction card, I explained how to choose a judge, match captions to photos, and score points. All of this is included in my template!

Step 4: Arrange Your Cards for Printing

Here’s where you can save yourself quite a bit of paper! Rather than printing each card individually, you’ll arrange multiple cards onto larger sheets in Canva.

Set Up Your Canva Printing Layouts

Here’s where you can save yourself quite a bit of paper! Rather than printing each card individually, you’ll arrange multiple cards onto larger sheets.

Start by creating two separate 8.5″ × 11″ design projects in Canva—one for your photo cards and another for your caption cards.

Download your individual photo and caption card designs as images, then upload them into their respective projects and arrange them as follows:

  • Photo cards: Two cards per sheet, with a separate page containing two matching card backs.
  • Caption cards: Six cards per sheet, with a separate page containing six matching card backs.

To make double-sided printing easier, arrange your pages so that each sheet of photo or caption cards is immediately followed by its matching card-back page.

layout instructions for making your custom meme photo cards ready to print
layout instructions for making your caption cards easy to print double sided

For example, your photo card project should look like this:

  • Page 1: Photo cards 1–2
  • Page 2: Matching card backs
  • Page 3: Photo cards 3–4
  • Page 4: Matching card backs

Continue alternating between card fronts and backs until you’ve arranged all your cards.

Time-saving tip: Once you’ve created your first set of card fronts and backs, simply duplicate those pages and drag and drop your next set of card images into the existing placeholders. This keeps the spacing and formatting consistent without having to recreate your layout every time.

Repeat the same process for your caption cards, arranging six captions per page followed by their matching backs.

Lastly, you might as well place your instruction card and cover card on one page to save on printing two sheets there!

Download Your Cards for Printing

Once you’ve arranged all your pages, you’re ready to download your printing files.

  1. Click Share in the upper-right corner of Canva.
  2. Select Download.
  3. Choose PDF Print as your file type.
  4. Select CMYK as your color profile, if available and recommended by your printing service.
  5. Under Select Pages, choose All Pages.
  6. Under Advanced Settings, toggle Flatten PDF on.
  7. Click Download.

Repeat this process for your Caption Cards and your single page of instruction and cover designs.

You’ll now have three complete PDF files—one containing all your photo cards and their matching backs, another containing all your caption cards and their matching backs, and a PDF with your instruction and cover sheet.

Step 5: Print Your Custom Meme Cards

Once you’ve downloaded your photo and caption card PDFs, it’s time to print!

You can print your cards at home if you have a printer that can handle heavier cardstock and double-sided printing, or have them professionally printed at a local print shop or office supply store.

I went with FedEx Office because I was short on time and needed my cards printed quickly. I chose double-sided printing on matte cover stock, which gave the cards a sturdy, professional feel.

The quality turned out great, but printing was definitely my biggest expense. If you have time to plan ahead, I’d recommend comparing prices at a few different printing services before placing your order.

Here’s the paper type and settings I used. I also spoke with someone there to confirm the flip setting for the double-sided print (keep reading for more on that!)

print settings for double-sided meme game card prints

Tips for Double-Sided Printing

Since each photo and caption card has a matching game-branded back, you’ll want to make sure everything lines up correctly when printing.

Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Choose double-sided printing. Your PDF should already have alternating pages of card fronts and backs, so each pair of pages will print on opposite sides of the same sheet.
  • Check your flip settings. Depending on your page orientation and printer, you may need to select flip on the long edge or flip on the short edge to keep both sides facing the same direction. For mine, I found out during my test print that I needed it flipped on the short edge.
  • Print at actual size (100%). Avoid settings that automatically resize your designs, since this can affect how the fronts and backs line up.
  • Check your margins. If your designs have backgrounds that extend to the edges of the cards, make sure you’ve allowed enough room for trimming so you don’t end up with unwanted white borders.

And my biggest tip? Always print a test sheet first!

I learned this one the hard way when my original prints came back with the fronts and backs facing opposite directions. Thankfully, it was something I could correct, but it’s definitely worth checking before printing an entire deck.

If you’re using a professional print shop, ask them to confirm the orientation and alignment of your double-sided designs before completing the order.

Custom meme cards being cut in progress

Step 6: Cut Your Meme Cards

You’re almost done! Now it’s time to cut out your photo and caption cards.

The easiest way to do this is with a paper trimmer or guillotine paper cutter, which will help you get clean, straight edges without having to cut every card individually with scissors.

Working with one printed sheet at a time, carefully line up your cards with the cutting blade and trim along the edges of each design. Take your time with the first few sheets to make sure you’re cutting evenly and keeping the front and back designs aligned.

Once everything is cut, separate your photo cards from your caption cards and stack them into their own decks.

Want rounded corners like mine? Use a corner-rounding punch after cutting your cards with a paper trimmer to create a more polished professional look (totally optional though!)

And that’s it! Your custom meme cards are officially ready to play. Now let’s give them a proper home.

a woman adding a custom made meme game cover to a Dollar Tree pencil box

Step 7: Make Your Own Meme Game Box

This might be my favorite little hack from the entire project. I wanted my finished game to look like an actual gift, not just a pile of cards tied together with ribbon.

So I headed to Dollar Tree and found a hard plastic pencil case that happened to be the perfect size for my cards. I designed a matching game cover and instruction sheet in Canva, printed them, and attached them to the outside and inside of the case with hot glue.

Don’t Forget the Photo Card Easel

You’ll also need a way to display the photo card during each round.

I found a mini wooden easel and canvas set at Dollar Tree for $1.25. You don’t need the canvas… so just save it for your next craft project!

Everything fit neatly inside, and the finished box looked surprisingly professional!

finished meme game present

Between the pencil case and easel, I spent just $2.50 on packaging and accessories.

Not bad, right?


How to Play Your Custom Meme Game

Once your game is assembled, it’s time to put those ridiculous photos and captions to work.

Here’s how we play:

  1. Choose a judge. One player selects a photo card and places it on the easel for everyone to see.
  2. Deal the caption cards. Each player starts with seven caption cards.
  3. Pick your funniest caption. Everyone except the judge chooses the caption from their hand that they think makes the funniest match with the photo.
  4. Choose a winner. The judge shuffles the submitted captions, reads them aloud, and picks their favorite.
  5. Score a point. Whoever played the winning caption earns the photo card as a point.
  6. Keep playing. Everyone draws back up to seven caption cards, and the next player becomes the judge.

You can play until someone reaches a set number of points or simply keep going until you’re ready to call it a night.

The best part is seeing how completely different captions can turn the same photo into something hilarious.


How Much Does It Cost to Make a Custom Meme Game?

Here’s what I spent making my version of Oh My Meme:

ItemCost
Double-sided printing at FedEx Office$78.00
Dollar Tree pencil case$1.25
Dollar Tree easel and canvas set$1.25
Total$80.50

That covered my 22 photo cards, 78 caption cards, and the packaging.

I already owned the other crafting supplies, so those costs aren’t included.

Could I have made this for less? Absolutely.

The printing was by far my biggest expense, and I think shopping around or printing at home could make a significant difference.

But even at $80.50, I ended up with a completely personalized Christmas gift that my nephew genuinely loved.

And considering how much time and effort goes into creating a custom game from scratch, I was pretty happy with the finished result.


Custom Meme Game FAQs

How many cards do you need for a DIY meme game?
Explain that you made 22 photo cards and 78 caption cards, but readers can start with a smaller deck.

What type of paper is best for printing meme cards?
Recommend sturdy cardstock or matte cover stock, noting that home printers have different paper-weight limitations.

Can you make a custom meme game without a Cricut or Silhouette?
Absolutely. Readers can create everything in Canva, print the cards, and cut them with a paper trimmer.


Make Your Own Custom Meme Game with My Canva Template

DIY meme game template

If you love this idea but don’t want to design every card from scratch, you can grab my editable Canva template to help make the process easier.

All you’ll need to do is add your own photos, customize your captions, personalize the game name and colors and you’re ready to go!


A Personalized Gift They’ll Actually Want to Play

I’ve made plenty of DIY Christmas gifts over the years, but this one was especially fun because it was so personal.

Between the ridiculous photos, the family inside jokes, and the captions that probably make absolutely no sense to anyone outside our family, it really was a game made just for my nephew.

And hearing that it was his favorite Christmas gift? Well, that was a pretty big win for this auntie.

Whether you’re making one for a birthday, graduation, Christmas, family reunion, or just because, a custom meme game is such a fun way to turn your favorite memories into something everyone can laugh about.

Now go dig through those embarrassing family photos. You’ve got a game to make!

Leave a Reply